




The proposal of the placement of this line has produced a variety of responses ranging from full-on support to those who vehemently oppose it to the point of forming organizations and committees aimed at banning it. One of the more controversial locations proposed for the CREZ line is through Palo Duro Canyon. On one hand, this portion of the transmission line is unavoidable for the CREZ line project; on the other hand, placing the CREZ line through the canyon will drastically alter the natural landscape. And based on the conversations I have had concerning this project, that struggle is at the heart of most of the arguments for or against the CREZ line. The purpose of the CREZ Transmission line is to provide a current for the energy from the growing wind turbine fields to be transported to collection stations and then passed on to urban and rural areas; so no matter how you look at it, these lines are inevitable.
One point that Andy Wilkinson brought up concerning those that oppose the line because of the way it will change the landscape is that the landscape that we view as ‘pristine’ or ‘natural’ has in fact already been altered by man-made means. Whether it be pump jacks, farms, power lines, gins, water towers, homes, etc. – the West Texas landscape has been evolving by our hand since the moment we set foot on it. And I think that all of this falls into a very real and very relevant topic that intertwines with the Ogallala Commons: what kind of an impact are we making on the planet? Are we destroying it or are we preserving it for ourselves and for future generations? It is true that constructing 15 story-high transmission lines through Palo Duro Canyon will drastically change the landscape; but without the introduction of clean-energy producing technology our means of existence will quickly become impossible.
I believe that we have to find a way to strike a balance between harnessing clean-energy from the environment while preserving the natural landscape, and in doing so we can move closer to being good stewards of the earth. It seems rather pointless to exploit and destroy something that we don’t even own-since it’s formation, the earth has gone through countless cycles and changes, and in the grand scheme of things we’re only here to inhabit a small portion of time on it.
I really enjoyed working on this project because I got to be a part of documenting a very innovative and controversial movement that is happening right in our own backyard, and I hope that I will be able to be involved in it's completion once that comes.











